In what might be the cruelest fake out in Bachelor history, Ben tells a grinning Olivia — rose in hand — that he CANNOT return her (fake anyway?) feelings. So, as underdog twin Emily squirms like a resident of Pig Island now that Ben (probably doesn't) knows her name, Olivia the Great is left stranded on Loser Island, her fat toes grounded in unforgiving sand. Faint sobs ring out against the crashing waves. But the sea doesn’t care, either. It’s as confused as she is.